Call a licensed agent(941) 555-0110TTY 711

Mon-Fri 8am-8pm, Sat 9am-2pm ET

Compare Medicare plans side by side

Original Medicare, a Supplement with Part D, or Medicare Advantage. See how the three paths differ on cost, doctors and travel.

The three paths compared

On a phone? Each option appears as its own card below.

Original Medicare, Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage compared
FeatureOriginal Medicare onlyParts A & BMedicare Supplement + Part DMedigap + drug planMedicare AdvantagePart C, usually with drugs
Monthly premiumPart B premiumPart B, plan often $0
Doctor choiceAny Medicare providerPlan network (HMO or PPO)
Referrals neededNoOften, on HMOs
Yearly out-of-pocket capNoneYes, set by plan
Prescription drugsNot includedIncluded in most plans
Dental, vision, hearingNot includedOften included
Coverage when traveling in the U.S.NationwideEmergencies, some PPOs more
Switching laterFlexibleEach fall during AEP

Swipe to see all three options

Original Medicare only

Parts A & B

Monthly premium
Part B premium
Doctor choice
Any Medicare provider
Referrals needed
No
Yearly out-of-pocket cap
None
Prescription drugs
Not included
Dental, vision, hearing
Not included
Coverage when traveling in the U.S.
Nationwide
Switching later
Flexible
Learn more

Medicare Advantage

Part C, usually with drugs

Monthly premium
Part B, plan often $0
Doctor choice
Plan network (HMO or PPO)
Referrals needed
Often, on HMOs
Yearly out-of-pocket cap
Yes, set by plan
Prescription drugs
Included in most plans
Dental, vision, hearing
Often included
Coverage when traveling in the U.S.
Emergencies, some PPOs more
Switching later
Each fall during AEP
Learn more

What a year could cost

Sample yearly totals for a 65-year-old in Sarasota County, including premiums and drugs. Your numbers will differ.

Healthy year

Two checkups and generic prescriptions.

Plan G + Part D
$2,640
Sample $0 premium HMO
$410

Moderate year

Specialist visits, an MRI and two brand-name drugs.

Plan G + Part D
$3,180
Sample $0 premium HMO
$2,350

Hard year

A hospital stay, surgery and physical therapy.

Plan G + Part D
$3,310
Sample $0 premium HMO
$6,900

Illustrative sample figures only, not a quote or a guarantee of costs. Benefits and costs vary by plan.

Which path fits you?

A Supplement + Part D tends to fit if you

  • Spend part of the year outside Florida
  • See specialists often or expect a surgery
  • Want to budget with almost no surprise bills
  • Are in your Medigap Open Enrollment Period now
Learn more

Medicare Advantage tends to fit if you

  • Stay in the Sarasota and Manatee area most of the year
  • Are comfortable using a network of doctors
  • Value a low or $0 monthly premium
  • Want dental, vision, hearing and fitness in one plan
Learn more

We do not offer every plan available in your area. Contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE for information on all of your options.

Compare with your real doctors and drugs

Free, no-pressure help comparing the plans we offer in your county. Most calls take about 20 minutes.

Licensed agents. TTY 711. Mon-Fri 8am-8pm, Sat 9am-2pm ET.

Cookie preferences

Choose which cookies you allow. You can change this at any time from the link in the footer.